Government pressing ahead with Making Tax Digital despite calls for further delay

The government's financial secretary shed further light on the details surrounding its Making Tax Digital (MTD) plans yesterday, including progress made in ongoing trials, ahead of the rollout in April.

A pilot phase for the MTD VAT service, running since April last year and opened to the public in October, has enrolled more than 16,500 businesses so far, with HMRC gearing up to make the service live from spring.

Financial secretary to the treasury Mel Stride MP also reiterated that penalties will not be issued due to late filings in the first year, just late payments and that any such penalties will be administered using a proportionate and "light-touch approach".

Moreover, a host of exemptions from MTD will apply to those who are disabled or face network difficulties.

"It has never been more important for businesses to be able to seize the opportunities that digital technology offers," Stride told the House of Commons, making his first statement on MTD since announcing a delay in 2017.

"In a world where businesses are already banking, paying bills and shopping online, it is important that the tax system keeps pace, but MTD is not just about providing a modern, digital service for businesses but about helping them get their tax right."

But the opposition accused the government of failing to adequately handle the digital transition to the detriment of UK businesses, and have called for a further delay until 2022 so small firms, in particular, have more time to adapt.

SMBs are already preoccupied with changes and investment needed, faced with the prospect of a no-deal Brexit, according to Labour's shadow financial secretary Peter Dowd MP, who also dismissed claims that HMRC is "ready" for MTD.

"Few people inside or outside the Government believe that HMRC is actually ready," he responded to Stride's statement, highlighting that the 16,500 figure represents just 0.5% of all eligible firms.

"To the best of my knowledge, it has the same problems as many of the businesses that will be required to begin digital reporting in 2019. Those concerns are echoed by tax professionals, who emphasise that the current timetable is unrealistic and unworkable for HMRC and the business community. "

The pair agreed, however, for the need to implement a modernised tax regime in principle, in light of the productivity gains as well as the making the tax process simpler for businesses.

Specifically, Stride highlighted that errors tied with using manual methods to either store or send tax information to HMRC altogether contribute £9.2 billion to the UK's tax gap. He said implementing MTD would make some headway towards closing this gap, to the tune of £1.2 billion by 2023/24.

The financial secretary added there are no plans to introduce MTD for income tax or corporation tax any earlier than 2020, and that the rollout of VAT MTD will be closely examined before any final decisions are made.